Creating new opportunities for international medical graduates

Extraordinary doctors for B.C. communities

Kirti Aneja was proud of her achievements when she began practising as an anesthesiologist in a rural community in India’s northern state of Punjab in 2007.

She’d wanted to be a doctor since she was a little girl playing with toy medical kits and was inspired by childhood visits to leprosy hospitals. She was happily married to her medical school sweetheart and expecting their first–born son.

But her family made a gut-wrenching decision: to leave their beloved homeland to pursue a better life for their children. And her passion to use her medical skills turned to serving people in her new country, Canada.

A long and winding journey

Dr. Aneja is an international medical graduate (IMG), one of a group of permanent residents or Canadian citizens trained outside of North America who are seeking to practise medicine in Canada.

The B.C. government has committed to increasing funding and partnering with the UBC Faculty of Medicine to expand the IMG program from 26 spaces today to a proposed 58 in 2017 in order to help meet the need for more doctors in underserved areas of B.C.

With an eye on ensuring high quality care in communities around the province, the process of integrating skilled and passionate medical graduates from overseas is rigorous.

While the U.S. and Canada share similar curriculum and accreditation for medical students, systems vary widely around the world. Many do not, for example, demand the same level of training in a clinical setting that is required of Canadian medical education.

In order to ensure the uniform skills and knowledge of medical graduates trained outside of North America, all IMGs are obliged to complete a series of exams.

Those who do best in the exams are then selected for clinical assessment—they work for three months in hospitals alongside experienced physicians—and on successful completion are then eligible to apply to residency training programs lasting two to seven years, depending on specialization, before they qualify for a license to practice.

Aneja had completed three years of residency training in India. But here in Canada, she had to start over.

“I’m a fighter. We came here for a better life for our family and our son, and I don’t give up easily,” says Aneja. While preparing for exams and looking after her young son, Aneja worked in Wal-Mart to make ends meet.

Aneja passed all her exams and the three-month BC-IMG clinical assessment in two-and-a-half years. She began her residency at St. Paul’s Hospital in July.

“I was determined to practise medicine in Canada, but it was definitely challenging,” says Aneja, whose husband is still in the process of qualifying for residency training.

Suzanne Walter had a similar journey. Born and raised in B.C., Dr. Walter decided to be a doctor while traveling in Europe after graduating with a Bachelor of Science from UBC. Walter completed medical school at the University of Freiburg in Germany and returned to Vancouver in 2008.

It took her two-and-a-half-years to complete the required exams and assessments before beginning residency training in 2010.

“In retrospect, I might have been a little naïve about what it would take to come back to practise in B.C.,” says Walter, who admitted that at times she felt deserving of special consideration as a natural Canadian.

“But the longer I was in the program, the more I realized that all the IMGs are Canadians—some have been here as long as 10 years and separated from their partners or children. Most have family and children to support and some are supporting extended families abroad,” she notes.

“Many of the IMGs I know aren’t here for their own careers—they had a good life in their home countries as doctors. They were well-respected and made good money.” “They’re here because they want a better life for their children, and as a new mother myself, I get it.”

The challenges: expanding the program for areas that need it

There is no shortage of doctors like Aneja and Walter—indeed there is a high demand for limited IMG spaces. But the key is to meet the province’s needs: identifying what kinds of doctors are needed where, building teaching capacity in the province’s hospitals, and increasing funding.

The B.C. government has designated the majority of current IMG spaces for family practice. IMGs are trained in Victoria and in the Fraser region in addition to Vancouver. Additional sites, such as Strathcona and Kamloops are also being considered. And since the last round of  program expansion began in 2006, seven IMGs have remained to practise in the underserved area where they completed their return-of-service contract.

Adding more IMG residency training spaces must take into account the teaching capacity in hospitals, community clinics and individual practises and the safety of patients, says Dr. Willa Henry, director of UBC’s Family Practice Residency Program.

While undergoing training, residents take on primary responsibility for patients under the watchful eye and guidance of preceptors—senior physicians who serve double–duty as teachers. Training IMGs requires preceptors who are experienced with a wide range of cultures and clinical backgrounds, says Henry.

“All residents must have experience providing care from cradle to grave, and a variety of demographics and socio-economic status. We’re increasingly exposing them to different geographic regions and health care settings.”

Of course, there are limits to the number of senior physicians who can provide this level of training in underserved areas. And teaching capacity has already been stretched to accommodate the doubling of UBC’s medical graduates in the last decade.

Doubling homegrown doctors

“For many years, we did not produce as many doctors as needed, and relied mainly on recruiting internationally educated doctors who were eligible to practise in Canada independently,” says Dr. David Snadden, executive associate dean of education in the Faculty of Medicine.

Answering the challenge to not only educate more doctors, but also increase the number of family physicians in underserved areas, the province and the UBC’s Faculty of Medicine doubled the number of medical student spaces—from 128 prior to 2004 to 288 this year—and distributed their training across the province to Victoria, Prince George and Kelowna. After spending the first semester at the Vancouver campus, one third of the class complete their studies at a distributed site. The aim is that many will establish practices around the province.

The Northern Medical Program (NMP), first of the distributed sites, is particularly successful in this regard, with almost two–thirds of fully licensed graduates now practising family medicine in the Northern Health Authority.

For Aneja, the prospect of practising family medicine in an underserved community and working with a range of health professionals in Canada’s universal health care system fulfills
her childhood ambitions in ways she’d
never envisioned.

“India has a two-tier, public-private system, with the public system catering mostly to the poor and the private system operating much like a commercial industry—if you have money, you shop around for doctors who give you what you want,” she says. “The health care system here is much more collaborative. As a family physician, I’ll get to work with people from all walks of life and act as a gatekeeper to ensure my patients get the best care possible.”

Walter says her interactions with IMGs have highlighted the rigor of the system and importance of diversity in the medical profession.

“IMGs go through a very intense process in order to be qualified to practise here,” says Walter, who points out that many IMGs were specialists in their home country before entering into family practice in B.C.

“They have a lot of specialized knowledge and are able to provide culturally sensitive care that’s especially important in today’s multicultural society.”

Despite a detour in the Wal-Mart photo department, Aneja says the journey has been well worth it.

“Looking back, if I had never come to Canada, I wouldn’t have learned what I’m capable of,” she says. “I wasn’t unhappy with my own world, but I would have missed this world.”

Related topics:

UBC Reports | Vol. 58 | No. 12 | Dec. 5, 2012

Kirti Aneja originally qualified as a doctor in India, before immigrating to Canada. Martin Dee Photograph

Kirti Aneja originally qualified as a doctor in India, before immigrating to Canada. Martin Dee Photograph

Share This

Rapid growth of medical training in B.C.

Working with the provincial government, UBC has already more than doubled the number of doctors it is training in the past decade, and is expanding spaces to bring in doctors trained outside of North America.

Completed expansion of spaces in UBC’s medical school

Planned expansion of spaces for the international medical graduate program

Pressure on B.C.’s teaching capacity

Much of MD undergraduate training, and most post-graduate training occurs in hospitals and clinics. Rapid growth in the medical school spaces has put a premium on teaching sites that meet these criteria:

Appropriate case mix
To meet learning objectives set by Canada’s accreditation body, a teaching site must have a variety of patients and health issues

Case volume
Sites must provide a high volume of general and specialized cases for students to practice skills, learn procedures.

Clinical faculty
Teaching is done by clinical faculty who are practicing doctors. There must be enough doctors willing to provide bedside teaching and participate in faculty development.

Rapid growth in medical school spaces has increased the number of clinical teaching physicians from 2,500 in 2004 to 5,000 in 2012. Shortages in certain areas, for example family physicians, creates challenges for further rapid expansion.

Who decides how many doctors are needed?

The B.C. Ministry of Health works with B.C.’s health authorities and UBC to determine the health and human resource needs of the province, and determine the number of trainees it can fund.

The government has put a priority on access to care for people in mid-sized urban centres and rural and remote communities. The most urgent need is for family physicians, pediatricians, psychiatrists and internists.

More stories from this issue

a place of mind, The University of British Columbia

UBC Public Affairs
310 - 6251 Cecil Green Park Road
Vancouver, BC
Canada V6T 1Z1
Tel: 604.822.3131
Fax: 604.822.2684
E-mail: public.affairs@ubc.ca

Emergency Procedures | Accessibility | Contact UBC | © Copyright The University of British Columbia